Louisiana has carried out its first-ever execution using nitrogen gas, putting Jessie Hoffman Jr. to death on March 18, 2025 at Louisiana State Penitentiary in Angola. The execution marks a significant shift in capital punishment, making Louisiana one of the few states to use nitrogen hypoxia as an alternative to lethal injection.
The Crime and Conviction
Hoffman was convicted for the 1996 abduction, rape, and murder of 28-year-old Mary “Molly” Elliot, a New Orleans advertising executive. Prosecutors said Hoffman forced Elliot to withdraw money from an ATM before driving her to a remote area in St. Tammany Parish, where he assaulted and fatally shot her.
He was arrested shortly after the crime and sentenced to death in 1998. Appeals spanning more than two decades failed to overturn his conviction.
Execution Details
Hoffman’s execution began at 6:31 p.m., using nitrogen gas as the lethal agent. He declined to make a final statement. According to witnesses, the process took 19 minutes, during which Hoffman displayed signs of distress, including visible convulsions before he was pronounced dead at 6:50 p.m.
This execution is part of Louisiana’s move to revive the death penalty, following a 15-year pause due to challenges with lethal injection drug availability.
Legal Battles and Controversy
Hoffman’s attorneys had fought to block the execution, arguing that nitrogen hypoxia is an untested and potentially inhumane method. They raised Eighth Amendment concerns, stating it could lead to unnecessary suffering.
Additionally, his lawyers claimed the nitrogen gas method violated his Buddhist beliefs, as it could interfere with meditative breathing during his death. However, the U.S. Supreme Court denied his appeal, allowing the execution to proceed.
Ethical Concerns Over Nitrogen Gas
The use of nitrogen hypoxia in executions remains a highly controversial topic. Critics argue that:
-
The method is experimental and lacks human testing.
-
Louisiana bans nitrogen gas for euthanizing animals, raising concerns about its use on humans.
-
The execution showed visible signs of suffering, contradicting claims that nitrogen gas is painless.
Hoffman’s execution sets a precedent for future nitrogen gas executions in the U.S. As Louisiana resumes capital punishment, debates over the ethics and legality of this new method are likely to intensify.
For now, the national conversation on the death penalty is reignited, with strong opinions on both sides about whether this execution represents justice or a dangerous precedent.